Search This Blog

Tuesday, January 17, 2012

Response to Gabor Rona

Many thanks to Gabor Rona for taking the time to continue this conversation.  There’s a lot in Rona’s post, but I want to cut to the heart of the conceptual issue here regarding the inter-operation of these bodies of law.

In terms of the relationship between IHL and IHRL, and the notion that IHL is a lex specialis, Rona ascribes to me a view that he describes as framework exclusion, as opposed to the more reasonable rule exclusion.  Actually, though, I think I would be willing to subscribe to rule exclusion myself, so we should be on the same page.

Rule exclusion, I take it, means that if there is an applicable rule of IHL on a given point, then IHL applies and IHRL does not apply.  Again, I’m happy with that point of view, but I’m not sure that everyone else is.

For example, in the Israeli Targeted Killings decision, the court applied the IHL rule that allows the targeting of civilians who are directly participating in hostilities (DPH).  As everyone knows, IHL permits the intentional targeting of civilians who DPH because they perform the function of combatancy.  However, the Israeli TK decision went further.  It concluded, in para. 40, that “a civilian taking a direct part in hostilities cannot be attacked at such time as he is doing so, if a less harmful means can be employed.”  The court then went on to discuss proportionality and the need to attempt capture (if feasible), rather than kill, based on the notion of proportionality.

This is a curious result.  The DPH standard is clearly an IHL rule.  However, the need to attempt capture (if feasible) of an individual engaged in combatancy is not a core IHL concept.  Rather, it allegedly stems from IHRL.  That’s why many people have interpreted the TK decision as reading IHRL norms into the applicable IHL norm in that case.

So what’s at issue here is the co-applicability of IHRL and IHL with regard to the same rule.  It’s precisely that kind of co-applicability that I find curious.  Even under the “rule exclusion” notion of lex specialis, it is hard to countenance. How do both bodies of law apply at the same time with regard to the same norm?  That’s one of the reasons why the development of the ICRC Interpretative Guidance on Directly Participating in Hostilities became so contentious.  The Interpretative Guidance document followed the methodology of the Israeli TK decision, to the apparent dismay of some of the participants in the project.

I don’t have a strong view about detention, although one can see the current debate about detention through this lens.  I understand Kevin’s point to be that IHRL applies to detention in NIAC because there is no IHL rule regarding detention (until the end of hostilities) in NIAC.  I am inclined to disagree (though my mind remains open), but only because I think there is, in fact, an IHL rule regarding detention in NIAC.  First, there’s CA3 and APII, both of which demand certain treatment regarding detainees.  Second, I suspect that customary international law both permits detention until the end of hostilities in an NIAC and demands humane treatment of those detainees (though again my mind is open).  Marty and Steve’s post suggests that the detention rules of IAC apply by virtue of analogy in NIAC, but I think the better formulation is to suggest that some of those detention rules apply by virtue of custom.  That being said, I don’t have a particular view on the specifics of which detention rules apply by custom, and I wouldn’t want to be put in the position of defending the current Administration’s view or practice on this.  Rather, I want to emphasize the underlying structure of this debate, which is the existence or non-existence of an IHL norm regarding detention that applies in any given factual circumstance. 

At a certain point, the applicable rules of IHL, (including the customary ones applicable in NIAC), become so comprehensive that one might describe them as a framework, though I don’t think much hinges on this language.  The framework of IHL is essentially the core concepts of combatants/civilians/DPH-CCF, and much of it is now jus cogens.

It strikes me as curious that human rights activists are so quick to cabin CIL application of the IHL rules of IAC to NIAC.  To my ear, it is one of the great advancements of the last few decades: that the rules of warfare must be respected and that no nation can ignore them simply because the armed conflict is internal. (Incidentally, this was also the great fault of the early Bush Administration: to audaciously proclaim that the armed conflict with al-Qaeda was unconstrained by IHL and LOW principles.)  It also strikes me that it is one of the great advancements that ICL case law has given us. Why do some human rights activists resist this laudable move? I suppose they want to fight the expansion of IHL norms because, in their absence, IHRL norms can swoop in to fill the gap, and in the process better protect the rights of the vulnerable. I’m not sure I share this strategic vision, though my skepticism does not make their view wrong.  (Ultimately, I have more faith that IHL, as a body of law, will make the situation on the ground better.)  The legal fight, though, is about the existence of the underlying IHL norm. 

One final quick point.  Rona says a few things about the relationship between IHL and domestic criminal law that I obviously agree with, but also a couple of points that I disagree with.  First, the agreement: of course there is room for domestic criminal law during armed conflict.  The privilege of combatancy changes the underlying norm regarding killing (which is what I was talking about in my original post), but if an unprivileged combatant kills someone then he has absolutely violated domestic criminal law -- absent self-defense of course.  This then raises the further question of whether the killing also violates the LOW (killing in violation of the laws of war) and could be prosecutable by a military commission.  Kevin and a number of others have written extensively about this theory and I share their concerns about it.  Undeniably, though, this hypothetical killing represents a violation of domestic criminal law.

Now the disagreement.  Rona goes on to say, regarding privileged combatants, “should they engage in rape, the use of biological weapons, torture of detainees or dozens of other violations of the laws of war, domestic criminal law – namely war crimes law – is the place to go for accountability.”  That doesn’t really make sense to me.  The place to go for accountability in such a situation is ICL because war crimes are one of the three core crimes of ICL.  Now, it is true that the conduct might also violate domestic criminal law if there is an applicable criminal law norm in question.  So a rape could potentially be prosecuted as a war crime under ICL or it could be prosecuted under the criminal law of one of the interested states (either based on territorial jurisdiction or active personality).  Both bodies of law prohibit the conduct because their respective norms are basically co-extensive.

But that’s not really an example of co-application in the sense that interests me.  In the war crime case, two or more bodies of criminal law (one international, the others domestic) prohibit the same conduct.  Co-application of IHRL and IHL involves the importation of principles of IHRL to inform one’s understanding of rules that are governed by IHL.  In the Israeli TK decision, this took the form of severely restricting the principle as it existed under IHL, which is what generated so much controversy at the ICRC.

Here’s a better, and more extreme, example.  Suppose the domestic penal law of country A prohibited the possession and use, not of biological weapons, but of automatic weapons (machine guns). Could an entire army be prosecuted for violating this domestic criminal law?  In that case, the domestic law would severely restrict – in fact eviscerate -- the IHL norm (privileged combatancy), and there would be something specious about permitting co-application of the norms in this context.


Anonymous said...

recall that the Israeli Ct. used a European standard from a rigid European Convention on Human Rights and not the global standard, which is far less limiting, in ICCPR art. 6's prohibition merely of "arbitrary" killings. IHL is actually more limiting in some respects than the global IHR standard, as explained in my 19 J. Transnat'l L. & Pol'y 237 (2010) article and a shorter follow-up essay in 39 Denver J. Int'l L. & Pol'y 569, 573-74 (2011), available at
annon = jj Paust

Ranveer Patil said...

Nice to see read that you have some knowledge about acne treatment cure...
Rising Pune Supergiants Team Squad Captain Name
GL Players List
Royal Challengers Bangalore Jersey logo Images

Karan Arora said...

Mother’s Day Quotes For Cards
Happy Mother’s Day Sayings
Happy Mother’s Day Quotes Status recuperar hd said...

I laughed out loud, shed some tears … Scrambled Eggs is a theatrical feast for women of all ages and the men who love them!" and CBS’ Magee Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real." recuperar hd

Happy Mothers day greetings 2016 said...

mothers day sms 2016 ||
happy mothers day sms 2016 ||

best mothers day sms 2016 |||

mothers day messages 2016 ||

happy mothers day messages 2016 ||

Top mothers day messages 2016 /||


mothers day messages from daughter 2016 |
Top mothers day messages from daughter 2016 |

best mothers day messages from daughter 2016 |

mothers day SMS from daughter 2016 |


mothers day messages from son 2016 |
happy mothers day messages from son 2016 |
best mothers day messages from son 2016 |
mothers day sms from son 2016 |


funny mothers day SMS 2016 |
funny mothers day messages 2016 |


mothers day messages to friend 2016|
happy mothers day messages to friend 2016|

best mothers day messages to friend 2016|

Happy Mothers day poems 2016 said...

top mothers day wishes 2016 ||
top 20 mothers day wishes 2016 ||


Mothers day 2016 FB Status ||
Mothers day 2016 Facebook Status ||
happy Mothers day 2016 FB Status ||

happy Mothers day 2016 Facebook Status ||


mothers day wishes 2016 in Hindi ||
happy mothers day wishes 2016 in Hindi ||
top mothers day wishes 2016 in Hindi ||


mothers day wishes from daughter 2016 ||
happy mothers day wishes from daughter 2016 ||
mothers day 2016 from daughter ||
happy mothers day 2016 from daughter ||


funny mothers day wishes 2016 ||
Top funny mothers day wishes 2016 ||
best funny mothers day wishes 2016 ||


mothers day wishes to Friend mom 2016 ||
mothers day wishes 2016 Friend mom ||
Top mothers day wishes to Friend mom 2016 ||

best mothers day wishes to Friend mom ||


mothers day wishes 2016 from son ||
happy mothers day wishes 2016 from son ||

top mothers day wishes 2016 from son ||

best mothers day wishes 2016 from son ||

suhail alam said...

Happay Raksha Bandhan day 2016
Happy Raksha Bandhann 2016 sms
Best Sms wishes Of Raksha Bandhan 2016
Happy raksha bandhan 2016 sms

suhail alam said...

15 August Independence Day 2016
15 August Independence Day Wallpapers
15 August Independence Day Images
15 August Independence Day Quotes
15 August Independence Day Message
15 August Independence Day Wishes
15 August Independence Day Songs
15 August Independence Day Sms
15 August Independence Day whatsapp status
15 August Independence Day HD Flag Images
15 August Independence Day HD Pics
15 August Independence Day Sayings
15 August Independence Day Greetings
15 August Independence Day wallpaper 2016
15 August Independence Day 2016 slogan,thought
15 August Independence Day Emoji,Cliparts and Greetings
15 August 2016 sms wishes
15 August 2016 image
15 August 2016 Quotes Message
Happay Independence day 2016

Vinamilk Vinamilk said...

Big Head Soccer And Head Soccer is one of the popular games in our web site big head basketball and Big Head Football big head basketball and Big Head Soccer and big head basketball you will experience the most exciting game of football. Not only that Big Head Football and With Big Head Football and Head Soccer or Big Head Soccer is the compelling game of adrenaline sports including football. In the site head soccer there are games like Big Head Football and Head Soccer and head soccer and head soccer unblocked I wish you enjoyable experience with soccer heads and head soccer 2 and big head basketball or big head soccer

key west knee injury lawyer said...

You’ve got some interesting points in this article. I would have never considered any of these if I didn’t come across this. Thanks!key west knee injury lawyer

Vintage Rugs said...

Buy Online Gifts and Silver Jewelry at very attractive price online at We sales best Online Gift Items and all type Jewelry Online for the cheapest price at Vintage Rugs

Rakhi Semwal said...

happy Dussehra 2016
happy Dussehra Images 2016
happy Dussehra Wallpapers 2016
happy Dussehra Greetings 2016
Halloween Day 2016
Halloween Day Quotes 2016
Halloween Day Costumes Ideas 2016

facelift atlanta said...

theatrical feast for women of all ages and the men who love them!" and CBS’ Magee Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real."facelift atlanta

Ponting Ricky said...

happy Dussehra 2016
happy Dussehra Images free download
happy Dussehra Wallpapers free download
happy Dussehra Greetings
happy Dussehra Message
happy Dussehra Wishes
happy Dussehra Quotes
happy Dussehra Pictures in HD
happy Dussehra Cards
happy Dussehra Songs

Ponting Ricky said...

Halloween Day 2016
Halloween Day Quotes
Halloween Day Costumes Ideas
Halloween Day Wallpapers
Halloween Day Images
Halloween Day Message
Halloween Day Wishes
Halloween Day SMS
Halloween Day Greeting Cards
Halloween Day Poems

Halloween Day Quotes said...

Happy Veterans Day 2016
Veterans Day
Veterans Day Quotes
Veterans Day Images
Veterans Day Sayings
Veterans Day Wallpapers
Veterans Day Greetings

Halloween Day Quotes said...

Veterans Day SMS
Veterans Day Poems
Veterans Day Message
Veterans Day Pictures
Veterans Day Cards
Happy Thanksgiving Day 2016
Thanksgiving Day
Thanksgiving Day Images
Thanksgiving Day Wallpapers

Alternative Clothing said...

This post is really nice and informative. I am feeling happy to comment on this post.Alternative Clothing

ios icon pack said...

First I dont understand why share this and now after reading this I know this is really helpful info shared with everyone.ios icon pack said...

Thanks a lot for enjoying this beauty blog with me. I am appreciating it very much! Looking forward to another great blog. Good luck to the author! all the best!

punjabisong said...

new punjabi song

Rio de Janeiro tours said...

I must say, I thought this was a pretty interesting read when it comes to this topic. Liked the material.Rio de Janeiro tours

cara menggugurkan kandungan said...

for beginners like me need a lot of reading and searching for information on various blogs. and articles that you share a very nice and inspires me

web design inspiration said...

Thank you very much for told me about the such a good writing plane… It is so informative about the essay and study writing.web design inspiration

Paise Kaise Kamaye said...

paise kaise kamaye
paise kaise kamaye
Blog se paise kaise kamaye

Paise Kaise Kamaye said...

Australia Day
Republic Day 2017
australia day Animated GIF
Australia day 2017
Happy Australia Day Animated GIF
Australia Day Wallpapers
Republic day 2017
Republic day

Paise Kaise Kamaye said...

Happy Australia Day animation
Happy Australia Day
Australia Day hd image
Australia Day hd image

Anonymous said...

Kiss Day 2017 Images

Kiss Day HD Images

Kiss Day 2017 Photos

Kiss Day HD Photos

Kiss Day 2017 Whatsapp DP

Kiss Day Images

KIss Day image

Kiss Day image 2017

Imran ismailbhai mansuri said...

good friday

good friday quotes


easter quotes

how to send money overseas said...

Good blog post. I want to thank you for interesting and helpful information and I like your point of view. Thank you!how to send money overseas

suhail alam said...

Happy Easter Day 2017
Happy Easter Sms Wishes 2017
Happy Easter message 2017
Happy Easter poems 2017
Good Friday image 2017
Happy Passover day 2017
Happy Passover text sms2017

suhail alam said...

Happy Good Friday 2017
Why Celebrated Good Friday
When is Good Friday 2017
Good Friday Wallpaper 2017
Good Friday Message 2017
Good Friday sms wishes 2017
Good Friday image 2017
easter day quotes 2017
Good Friday animated gif image 2017
Good Friday Quotes 2017

Kuldeep said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
legal reputation said...

I was looking at some of your posts on this website and I conceive this web site is really instructive! Keep putting reputation

Anonymous said...

ap 10th Class Result 2017

ap ssc results 2017 ap
ap 10th result 2017 name wise
ssc results 2017 telangana grade wise

sell iphone 7 said...

It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.sell iphone 7

I Inova Infra said...

Thanks for sharing this article

Lithium polymer battery said...

I really like the dear information you offer in your articles. I’m able to bookmark your site and show the kids check out up here generally. Im fairly positive theyre likely to be informed a great deal of new stuff here than anyone.Lithium polymer battery

Memorial Day 2017 said...

memorial day 2017 quotes
memorial day ecards
memorial day wallpapers
memorial day photos
memorial day pictures
memorial day


memorial day greeetings cards
memorial day wishes
memorial day sayings quotes

Memorial Day 2017 said...

Mothers Day Poems Wishes
Mothers Day Greetings Cards
Mothers Day Cards
Friendship Day Images
mother's day

images 2017

Free Recharge Trick

Memorial Day 2017 said...

Mothers Day SMS
mothers day sms wishes
Good Morning SMS
Good Morning

Messages For Girlfriend

Mothers Day SMS QuotesMothers Day SMS
mothers day sms wishes
Good Morning SMS
Good Morning

Messages For Girlfriend

Mothers Day SMS Quotes

contract solution said...

All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind. thanks for sharing the information keep updating. looking forward for more posts.Thankscontract solution

Crafts Need said...

Nice Article I Have Read Today Thanks !!!!!!!!

cost to refinance said...

Thanks for sharing nice information with us. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, I would like to bookmark the page so I can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.cost to refinance

Follow said...

10 Saal Zindagi Lyrics

Lambo Wali Girl Lyrics

mustang lyrics jimmy

Alcohol lyrics paul g

o jatt lyrics

Muqabla Lyrics Ninja

mubarakan lyrics badshah

warning lyrics a kay

Deepesh said...

thanks for the post..
wwe summerslam live streaming
summerslam live streaming
summerslam live 2017 streaming

india first prime minister said...

first prime minister of india india first prime minister first pm of india indias first prime minister

paytm customer care no said...

paytm customer care no paytm customer care email ID paytm customer care number paytm customer care number noida paytm customer care number toll free

uber customer care number said...

uber customer care number uber customer care contact number uber toll free contact number uber customer care hyderabad uber customer care email id