Search This Blog

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Kiobel Do-over: Will the Torturer Remain Hostis Humani Generis?

Yesterday the Supreme Court issued a one-page order that directed the Kiobel case returned to the calendar for re-argument next term and also ordered the parties to brief a new question: whether the Alien Tort Statute permits an alien to sue in U.S. federal court for crimes committed in the territory of another sovereign.

When the Kiobel case was originally argued last week, the lawyers thought they were arguing about whether corporations can be responsible, under international law, for human rights abuses, or whether the corporate liability question is governed by U.S. domestic law even in ATS cases. 

As it happens, though, the justices were more intent on asking about the exterritorial application of the ATS to torts committed outside of the United States.  The lawyers were taken a bit by surprise, and the issue was not explicitly briefed by the parties.  Everyone assumed that the extraterritorial reach of the ATS was an underlying assumption of the debate.  Most litigants, ever since Filartiga, have assumed that the ATS had extraterritorial reach – and that was the entire point of ATS litigation.

The briefing and second-round oral argument will presumably center around the presumption against extra-territorial application of U.S. statutes, something that Anthony Colangelo has recently written about.  (Colangelo concludes that the relevant presumption as to the ATS ought to be Charming Betsy, not the Morrison presumption against extra-territoriality).  Although it might seem like the Court is backtracking a bit, the only Supreme Court case directly on point is Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain, which had a strong connection to the U.S. since the kidnapping scheme, although executed in Mexico, was formulated and completed here.

And as others have already noted, the language of the re-argument order is interesting.  The court specifically wants the parties to address the applicability of the ATS for torts committed in other countries – not torts committed outside the United States.  The difference is subtle, but piracy is committed outside the U.S. but not within another country; it happens in international waters.  At least some members of the Court apparently want to concede that the ATS covers piracy outside of the U.S., but not torts committed within another sovereign jurisdiction.

Human rights litigators are worried that this case is turning ought far worse than they ever imagined.  The went into Kiobel worried that corporate aiding and abetting cases – the best cases – would be curtailed once corporations were deemed immune from suit under the ATS.  But if the rehearing order is any indication, what’s at stake now is the entirely of Filartiga-style ATS litigation. 

If the ATS does not have extraterritorial reach, one wonders whether the torturer can still be, in the words of Judge Kaufman, the hostis humani generis – the enemy of all mankind.  I guess they could still be an enemy -- just not a litigant here.

4 comments:

Lena Harris said...

The Kiobel case is one of the most controversial legal cases in recent history that tackles international human rights law. I believe that the Royal Dutch/Shell should be held liable and punishable in this class action and be branded as hostis humani generis.

class action attorney

sarah saad said...

شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بجدة
شركة نقل عفش بالدمام
شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بجدة
شركة نقل اثاث بجدة

Happy Room said...

Thanks, you guys that is a great explanation. keep up the good work in your granite blog !

Luis Francis said...

Nice post.Create a word bank is an interesting approach to writing your essays. Before starting to write essays, you have to choose topic of essay and write thesis for your essay. Thesis is the main part of the essay. From the thesis readers will get to know the idea of your essay. Once you have done with thesis, then think about the topic and make main points for your topic in different ways. And make list of the words which are not closely related to your topic.
Act like an reported for yourself; when you are assigned the topic, then study the question properly and explore the thesis of your topic. Ask the question to yourself of the topic and get more information of your topic which you will be used in your essay. a strong essay is the one which explains the lot of content in brief way. This process of acting like a reporter will help you to get more quotes, data and information of your topic.
Create topic sentence for your best essay writing service ; topic sentence is the first sentence in the section and it summarizes the rest of section. When writing your essay you can create them first to help you to stay on your track of your essay.
Argue both sides; if you want to write long and complex essays, before you start writing it might help you to outline both side of your argument. You have to choose one side to focus on, when you write the essay. To developing thesis speech, having side by side points is very useful. By arguing the opposite side of your essay argument, you will learn that which points you need to better address in you r essay while writing. You will know more about your topic and you will get more data of your topic.