Search This Blog

Loading...

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

John Brennan finalizes the Obama Doctrine on TKs

On Monday, John Brennan gave the clearest and most detailed exegesis of the Obama Administration’s doctrine of targeted killings.  Brennan addressed the legal and ethical justifications for drone strikes, as well as their efficacy.  Although the speech in many ways built on previous speeches delivered by Harold Koh (State), Eric Holder (Justice), Jeh Johnson (Defense), and Stephen Preston (CIA), I noticed some changes in emphasis that are worth exploring.

As a first point, Brennan made a point of explaining what the IHL requirement of “military necessity” means – in particular “the requirement that the target have definite military value.”  It seems to me that this classical definition of military necessity is often overlooked by international lawyers.  The confusion stems from the fact that the concept of necessity exists in almost every legal regime, but it operates differently in each context.  Necessity in criminal law means something different than necessity in the Law of Armed Conflict.  In the former, it means something like “no other alternative” or “least restrictive means,” but in the latter it means that there is a military rationale (i.e. an expected military advantage to be gained) for the attack.  That technical meaning for military necessity goes back at least as far as Francis Lieber.

Second, Brennan said that the US was aware of the fact that its legal arguments in this context would establish precedents – presumably under customary law – and that the US was cognizant of the fact that our adversaries would then be following these rules in their deployment of drones against us.  This showed some sensitivity to what Jeremy Waldron, in the recent TK volume published by OUP, has called a “neutral principle.”

Third, Brennan’s general discussion of capture (if feasible) was couched as a policy preference, not an obligation under international law.  He was clear that there is no obligation under international law to attempt capture first (a bit of a contentious point with some human rights lawyers).  I think there was some confusion on this point after Holder’s speech at Northwestern, where Holder discussed the duty to capture.  If I understood Brennan correctly, the duty to capture (if feasible) only applies to citizens, like Anwar al-Awlaki, though he neither identified the source of this requirement nor did he explicitly state that the duty to capture applies as a Constitutional matter to citizens.  But presumably it is a constitutional norm stemming from Tennessee v. Garner and its progeny.  And presumably the requirement only applies outside of a traditional hot battlefield.  For my part, I wish he had been more explicit on these points.

As a final point, Brennan’s account of what constitutes a significant threat, and implicitly whether it is an imminent threat or not, was more convincing than what Holder said.  Brennan distinguished between hypothetical threats and actual threats – and excluded situations including “the mere possibility that a member of al-Qa’ida might try to attack us at some point in the future.”  To my ear, that sounds narrower and more convincing than Holder’s account, which emphasized (and maybe even over-emphasized) the use of force in its preemptive and preventive forms, both of which are controversial under international law.

14 comments:

Ranveer Patil said...

This blog is a great source of information which is very useful for me.
Kolkata Knight Riders Team Squad Captain Name
ICC t20 worldcup qualified teams
Royal Challengers Bangalore Jersey logo Images

Manish Dangar said...

I like this a lot. Thank you for sharing. I'm always looking for upcycles like this. In the end, you don't know it was a shipping pallet to begin with!

icc world twenty 20
post office recruitment 2016
rio olympic 2016
hollybollybuzz
happydiwalifestival
happy christmas festival
happy new year festival 2016
post office exam 2016
ipl live streaming 2016
finance times news 2016
Boomshape
gseb ssc hsc result
maru bharat

Mihir said...

that's what am i looking for a long... thanks.. I appreciate your work.. nice article... Awesome
Happy Holi Messages
Happy Holi quote
happy holi msg 2016
happy holi shayri
holi color 2016

Vikramjeet Singh Hayer said...

Hello, I just loved reading your article. Also vist my blog for IPL 2016 Schedule, Fixtures, Matches timings .cheers.

Megan Valish said...

T20 World Cup Final
England vs Afghanistan
India vs Bangladesh
Online Health Care Tips
IPL 2016 Schedule
Dhoom 4
T20 World Cup 2016
Ipl 2016
Ipl 2016 Schedule
Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016
IPL 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Match
Vivo ipl 2016 live
Vivo ipl 2016 schedule
Watch IPL Live
IPL Live Streaming
ipl 2016 opening ceremoney
IPL 2016 Draft
IPL 2016 Auction
IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Schedule
VIVO IPL 2016 Match
VIVO IPL 2016 Draft
VIVO IPL 2016 Auction
VIVO IPL 2016 Live
ipl 2016 Live Streaming
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Live Streaming
IPL 9 Schedule
IPL 9 Match
ipl 2016 Live Score
IPL 9 Draft
IPL 9 Auction
IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
ipl 2016 Opening ceremony
VIVO IPL 9 Schedule
VIVO IPL 9 Match
ipl 9 Live Match
ipl 9 Schedule Time table
Vivo ipl live score
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
VIVO IPL 9 Live Streaming

Karan Arora said...

Mothers Day Image
Mothers Day Images
Mother’s Day Images
Happy Mothers Day Images
Happy Mother’s Day Images
Mothers Day Profile Pics
Mothers Day Cover Photos
Mothers Day Images For Facebook

An Binh said...

Tronng văn phòng công ty với mỗi phòng ban đều có những chức năng công việc khác nhau cho nên việc lựa chọn mua bàn làm việc nhân viên cũng hòa toàn khác nhau tùy vào mục đích sử dụng của văn phòng. Cho nên việc lựa chọn mua sản phẩm nội thất văn phòng như bàn, ghế, tủ… đều phải có sự thống nhất và dựa vào không gian văn phòng làm việc mà lựa chọn được mẫu sản phẩm cho phù hợp nhất. Hiện nay trên thị trường nội thất có rất nhiều sản phẩm bàn văn phòng giá rẻ tphcm khác nhau nhiều giá, mẫu mã và chức năng.
Bàn làm việc văn phòng cho nhân viên thì phụ thuộc vào diện tích khá nhiều. Những chiếc bàn làm việc đơn có hộc sẽ được sử dụng cho những căn phòng rộng để giúp mỗi người có một khoảng làm việc riêng và cũng để văn phòng không bị trống trải. Tuy nhiên, ở những thiết kế nội thất văn phòng hiện đại đề cao tính gắn kết nên lại chọn những kiểu bàn làm việc văn phòng giá rẻlớn dạng đôi để tập trung từng nhóm nhân viên lại với nhau. Vách ngăn vẫn sẽ giúp mỗi người có những khoảng không gian riêng cho mình. Cho nên để có một văn phòng đẹp hiện đại các nhà quản lý cần phải chọn mua được sản phẩm nội thất văn phòng giá rẻ hcm sao cho hài hòa với văn phòng cũng như là không gian làm việc tốt nhất. Chính vì thế các nhà thầu thiết kế cũng nên cân nhắc về việc tư vấn cho khách hàng của mình chọn được mẫu sản phẩm nội thất sử dụng tốt nhất.

Pankaj Rai said...

Euro 2016 Schedule
Euro 2016 Live Streaming
Euro 2016 Predictions
Uefa euro 2016 final
UEFA European Championship Fixture
Uefa Euro 2016 Venues
Euro 2016 Preview
uefa euro 2016 standings
Euro 2016 Highlights
Uefa euro 2016 theme song
Uefa euro 2016 opening Ceremony
Uefa euro 2016 Opening Night
Uefa euro 2016 opening match
most famous things in the world
Euro 2016 schedule in pacific time
Euro 2016 schedule in Austrlian time
Euro 2016 schedule in Indian Times
Watch euro 2016 Live online
Watch euro 2016 Live Streaming online
Euro 2016 Teams Squad
Euro 2016 Teams Roaster
Euro 2016 schedule in Bangladesh times
Euro 2016 schedule in British times
Euro 2016 points table
euro 2016 Highlights
Euro 2016 Live Streaming
Euro 2016 Live Streaming in india
euro 2016 fixture
euro 2016 News
Uefa euro 2016 groups
Euro cup football 2016
watch euro 2016 online free

Megan Valish said...

Copa America 2016 Semifinal
copa america 2016 live streaming
copa America 2016 Final
copa America 2016 Live Online
Usa vs Argentina Copa America 2016 Semifinal
Colombia vs Chile Copa America 2016
Usa vs Argentina Live Streaming
Colombia vs Chile Live Streaming
Copa america Final
Watch Copa America Live Online
Copa America 2016 Semifinal
copa america 2016 live streaming
copa America 2016 Final
copa America 2016 Live Online
Usa vs Argentina Copa America 2016 Semifinal
Colombia vs Chile Copa America 2016
Usa vs Argentina Live Streaming
Colombia vs Chile Live Streaming
Copa america Final
Watch Copa America Live Online
Halloween 2016 Costumes Ideas
Happy Diwali 2016 Images
Get Passport Status
Passport Status
When Halloween 2016
Black Friday 2016 Deals
Ganesh Chaturthi 2016 Images
Independence Day 2016
Happy independence day 2016
Latest Government Jobs
Latest Bank Jobs
Champions Trophy 2017 Schedule
2017 Champions Trophy
Best Whatsapp Images
Narendra modi Speech
Top 10 Richest Cities In India

Raushni Singh said...

what is independence day
usa independence day 2016 Wishes
america independence day 2016 Quotes
Happy independence day 2016 images
happy 4th of july 2016 images
happy 4th of july 2016 pictures
independence day 2016 pictures
independence day 2016 pics
the independence day
4th july 2016 pictures
Happy 4th of july 2016 fireworks
4th july 2016 celebrations
Happy independence day 2016 Wishes
fourth of july 2016 quotes
independent quotes
4th of july 2016 wallpapers
4th of july 2016 photos
Happy 4th of july 2016 quotes
4th of july 2016 nail designs
4th of july 2016 nail Arts
Canada Day 2016 Graphics
happy birthday america
Canada Day 2016 Greetings
independence day 2016 sale
Happy Canada Day 2016
independence day history
july 4th 2016 sale
4th of july 2016 sales
Canada Day 2016 Quotes
4th of july 2016
4th of july 2016 events
july 4th 2016 fireworks

Tarun Upadhyay said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
Happy Independence Day
Happy Independence Day 2016
Happy Independence Day Images
Happy Independence Day Wishes
Happy Independence Day Messages
Happy Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Songs
Happy Independence Day Bhashan
Happy Independence Day Parade
Happy 4th of July
Happy 4th of July Fireworks
Happy 4th of July Images
Happy 4th of July USA Independence Day

Khushi Sharma said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
Happy Independence Day
Happy Independence Day 2016
Happy Independence Day Images
Happy Independence Day Wishes
Happy Independence Day Messages
Happy Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Songs
Happy Independence Day Bhashan
Happy Independence Day Parade

Dussehra celebrations said...

Rakhi Messages 2016 for Brother & Soldiers in Gujarati
Handmade Rakhi 2016 Gifts and Greeting Cards for Brother

Diya Gupta said...

Most Beauty, stunning and food looking Miss Bangalore Escorts Girls Diya Gupta, My Bangalore Escorts Service is 100% satisfaction service for you.

Bangalore Escorts Agency

Bangalore Escorts Agency

Bangalore Escorts Agency

Bangalore Escorts Agency

Bangalore Escorts Agency