Search This Blog

Sunday, May 20, 2012

Torture and Secrecy

I’ve been thinking a lot about secrecy lately, in part because Penn Law just hosted a fabulous conference this weekend on Secrecy and the Rule of Law.  One of the biggest problems the government is facing is the issue of who gets to make classification decisions, how they are made, and whether these decisions are impartial and equitable.

Two recent secrecy decisions prompt this concern – both dealing with Bush-era use of torture or enhance interrogation techniques during the conflict with al-Qaeda. 

Former CIA official Jose Rodriguez just published a strongly worded memoir that argues, without much qualification, that the torture of al-Qaeda suspects was necessary to protect the nation.  More specifically, Rodriguez discusses the torture of specific suspects and concludes that the killing of bin Laden, and other recent counter-terrorism successes, would not have occurred but for the torture of these suspects during the Bush Administration.  It is unclear how Rodriguez has the information to make this judgment with confidence, since his security clearance was presumably revoked after he left the CIA and he therefore has no direct access to the underlying information that led to – or did not lead to – the finding of Bin Laden, which happened after Rodriguez left the CIA.  In other words, how does he know?

At the same time, the detainees on trial before the 9/11 military commission operate under a strict rule of secrecy regarding torture, since their torture falls under the rubric of “intelligence methods and practices” that must remain secret.  So far so good.  But the manner in which this rule is being applied is incredibly strict, insofar as it extends to the detainees’ own recollection of the treatment that they were subject to during their custodial interrogations.  In other words, if the detainee speaks to his lawyer about how he was tortured, and the lawyer takes notes, those notes are then classified secret, because they relate to the government’s methods and practices.  The fact that it was the detainee himself who generated the document doesn’t matter.

The government’s argument, so far as I can tell, is that the relevant issue is whether the document is within the government’s custody or control, not who generated the document.  Since the detainee is in custody, these notes, even if they simply represent the detainee’s personal recollections, are within the custody or control of the government.  And they contain classified information about interrogation methods.  So they must remain secret and cannot be disclosed to the outside world, even if the detainees themselves may wish to publicly speak about the abusive treatment they were subjected to by government agents.

I am not questioning the propriety of this argument, though plenty of others have on First Amendment grounds (doesn’t everyone have the fundamental right to speak to the world about how the government is treating them?).  Rather, my point is far more narrow.  Are government officials making these classification decisions in a consistent and coherent manner?  Something seems amiss when the detainees can’t speak about the torture but former CIA officials can.  Now, I’m not claiming here that the result is unfair.  Rather, I’m simply claiming that these results strike me as inconsistent and incoherent, and ought to give us pause that the overall process of secrecy classifications is consistently administered.  Some critics might claim that the inconsistency generates unfairness, but even if you don’t care about fairness on behalf of the detainees, one ought to be worried here that the inconsistency is symptomatic of the system’s ineffectiveness – and that ought to worry everyone.


Unknown said...

Thanks you for this post… great information.
IPL 2016 live matches watch online here
MI New Team Players List
IPL 9 Time Table Schedule 2016 get here

Unknown said...

Booking IPL Ticket Online ipl9 buy tickets ipl live ipl live streaming ipl scoreipl cricket cricket live score ipl live score ipl 2016 ipl match VIVO IPL LIVE VIVO IPL SCORE VIVO IPL CRICKET
cricket live score ipl live score vivo ipl 2016 vivo ipl match 2016 ipl Buy IPL Tickets VIVO ipl9 buy tickets

Megan Valish said...

T20 World Cup Final
England vs Afghanistan
India vs Bangladesh
Online Health Care Tips
IPL 2016 Schedule
Dhoom 4
T20 World Cup 2016
Ipl 2016
Ipl 2016 Schedule
Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016
IPL 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Match
Vivo ipl 2016 live
Vivo ipl 2016 schedule
Watch IPL Live
IPL Live Streaming
ipl 2016 opening ceremoney
IPL 2016 Draft
IPL 2016 Auction
IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016 Schedule
VIVO IPL 2016 Match
VIVO IPL 2016 Draft
VIVO IPL 2016 Auction
VIVO IPL 2016 Live
ipl 2016 Live Streaming
VIVO IPL 2016 Live Streaming
IPL 9 Schedule
IPL 9 Match
ipl 2016 Live Score
IPL 9 Draft
IPL 9 Auction
IPL 9 Live
ipl 2016 Opening ceremony
VIVO IPL 9 Schedule
VIVO IPL 9 Match
ipl 9 Live Match
ipl 9 Schedule Time table
Vivo ipl live score
VIVO IPL 9 Live Streaming

Karan Arora said...

Mothers Day Image
Mothers Day Images
Mother’s Day Images
Happy Mothers Day Images
Happy Mother’s Day Images
Mothers Day Profile Pics
Mothers Day Cover Photos
Mothers Day Images For Facebook

Assignment Help said...

I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that's at the other blogs.
Assignment Samples

doctor lee said...

stand up comedy india
zakir khan videos
time place and venue of upcoming stand up comedy shows
Top Stand up comedy Shows
Stand Up Comedians

io games said...

I will be happy if you read my comment. I must say that I like all your posts and wait for new ones. That's because they seem so great and suitable for me. Thanks a ton for uploading your articles.
Short Ride game racing free || Jump Ball Blast Online games kids for school || online Downhill Rush

Unknown said...

Do you know that there are readers loving to read your posts everyday? So please write and post more. I choose to follow your writing because they bring me what I want. They have knowledge and information. I will support you a lot. Thanks 2 player games || Christmas Gifts Mania new game || How to make frozen fever cake girls games for free

Amit Kumar said...

top bollywood news in hindi - Check out the latest Bollywood news, hindi bollywood news today, box office collection updates, latest Hindi movie reviews & trailers of bollywood movies.

top bollywood news in hindi

Amit Kumar said...

Readyreviews is India's leading online platform in providing Best Product Reviews Buying Guides in India & Recommendations of Electronics & Gadgets, Home & Kitchen appliances, Wearable devices, Fashion, Musical Instruments, Health & Fitness.

Best Product Reviews and Comparisons

Praveen Bhardwaj said...

Dr. Rashmi offers cheap & best quality root canal treatment services at affordable price at thubarahalli Bangalore.

root canal clinic in thubarahalli bangalore

Anshu Singh said...

Looking for Ready to move in Independent Villa projects in Greater Noida.? Divine Residency offer best Villa Projects in Noida West. For more details visit website.

Independent Villa projects in Greater Noida

Anushka Singh said...

Searching web designing & Development Company at Vaishali Ghaziabad? Get best site designing, Internet Development Services in Noida, Greater Noida with customer satisfaction Services.

Web Design Company in Vaishali Ghaziabad

Anshu Singh said...

residential Freehold property in noida extension - Looking for residential Freehold property in noida extension? Divine Residency is one of the best real-estate developer, which provides residential Freehold property in Noida. Buy new residential Freehold property at best price online at BRD Info Tech Pvt. Ltd.

Anushka Singh said...

best website designing company in noida - Prashi Digitech is one of the leading web development Company in noida which provide you best website design, Internet Development Services at Noida, Greater Noida with customer satisfaction Services.

Praveen Bhardwaj said...

root canal in bangalore - Are you currently looking for the best dentist in Kundalahalli, Bangalore? Visit Atharv Skin And Smile for optimal clinic in Bangalore offer quality dental treatment. Reserve your appointment. said...

Very nicely written blog...Relly loved reading it...Please check my blogs for
Jaipur escorts
Jaipur escorts
Jaipur escorts
Delhi escorts
Guwahati escorts
Guwahati escorts
Guwahati escorts
Guwahati escorts