Search This Blog

Friday, November 30, 2012

Palestinian Statehood and the ICC


Yesterday the UN General Assembly voted to recognize Palestine as a non-member state, paving the way for full statehood for Palestine.  Although the legal status of Palestine has been a question of contention for years, the General Assembly vote may be the tipping point that brings Palestinian dreams of statehood to fruition.  Predictably, both the U.S. and Israel voted against the resolution.  A few close allies voted with U.S. and Israel (including Canada), though most allies simply abstained from the vote in order to avoid angering the U.S. and Israel.  The resolution passed by a wide margin, 138 in favor, 9 against, 41 abstaining.

What’s interesting is the arguments that the US has deployed against Palestinian statehood.  These arguments display a surprisingly central role for international criminal justice.

In particular, the US is concerned that the Palestinian Authority will now move to join the International Criminal Court as a signatory to the Rome Statute.  This would be the first move in an attempt by the Palestinian Authority to trigger the jurisdiction of the Court over crimes allegedly committed by Israel.  This would include scrutiny over Israeli bombing practices during the recent air war over the Gaza strip, and potentially previous conflicts as well.  Of course, this jurisdiction might also bring unwanted scrutiny over the indiscriminate rocket attacks that Hamas has launched against civilian centers in Israel, including Tel Aviv, an inquiry that the Palestinians may wish to avoid.  On the other hand, perhaps that would help delegitimize Hamas on the international stage, which is something the Palestinian Authority might indeed want.

Incidentally, the Palestinian Authority tried to trigger the ICC’s jurisdiction before, although its claim to statehood then was even weaker, and it simply deposited a "declaration" accepting the court's jurisdiction.  This move prompted a huge academic debate over whether the ICC's jurisdiction could be triggered in this manner by a proto-state like Palestine.  But even now, the Palestinian Authority may have some difficulty demonstrating its own statehood.  While recognition from the General Assembly is undoubtedly important and relevant, there is a control problem. Simply put, the Palestinian Authority has no control over Gaza City, which is controlled by Hamas.  In fact, Mahmoud Abbas isn’t even allowed inside the Gaza Strip, apparently.

Indeed, it appears clear that at least some countries voted in favor of the resolution to increase Abbas’ credibility and strengthen his hand against his more radical opponents in Hamas.  Supporting Abbas seems like the best chance for peace with Israel because the Palestinian Authority at least has a chance with negotiating a deal with Israel, unlike Hamas.  These are all pragmatic considerations that sound in realpolitik.

The last issue is the legal question of retroactivity.  Over at OJ, Kevin Heller notes that the Rome Statute allows a state party to grant retroactive jurisdiction to the court (for acts committed prior to the state's adoption of the Statute).  While this is true, it isn’t clear to me that a retroactive granting of jurisdiction would permit the ICC to exercise jurisdiction over acts that were committed before Palestine was even a state.  Of course, there doesn’t appear to be anything in the Rome Statute that precludes this possibility, but it certainly represents a far more expansive understanding of retroactive jurisdiction.  The answer depends, I think, on the deeper question of what ICC jurisdiction is meant to accomplish -- ending impunity for criminal conduct or helping to resolve international disputes that sparked international crimes.

24 comments:

Mihai Martoiu Ticu said...

==Of course, this jurisdiction might also bring unwanted scrutiny over the indiscriminate rocket attacks that Hamas has launched against civilian centers in Israel, including Tel Aviv, an inquiry that the Palestinians may wish to avoid.==

If one is prepared to kill for one’s country, to dye for one’s country, one should also be prepared to go to jail for one’s country. If they believe that rocket attacks were necessary, they should be prepared to test this premise in court.

Mihai Martoiu Ticu said...

correction: I mean 'die' not 'dye'.

andrewwilson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
andrewwilson said...

I am satisfied with your blog. Your post is dear. Thanks for sharing your precious comprehension with me.Driveways Newcastle

Harish Yes said...

You made some good points there. I searched this topic and found out that most people will agree with your post. packers and movers bangalore packers and movers bangalore marathahalli packers and movers marathahalli packers and movers hsr layout packers and movers btm layout packers and movers bommanahalli packers and movers whitefield packers and movers koramangala packers and movers jp nagar

Gwen said...

That is an interesting move by Palestine.

e-learning platform said...

Thank you very much for posting and sharing this great article.e-learning platform

conveyancing quotes said...

Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why waste your intelligence on just posting videos to your blog when you could be giving us something enlightening to read conveyancing quotes

recreation.tips said...

Cheers. Great post!! i must say and thanks for the tips. Post that you talk about this very nice, a lot of new things that I comes from your post.recreation.tips

rent a yacht in maimi said...

I have been checking out a few of your stories and i can state pretty good stuff. I will definitely bookmark your blog rent a yacht in maimi

kurzy excel said...

What a great source of information. Such a wonderful collection of new ideas. I'll definitely be back!kurzy excel

Nilesh sharma said...

Kerala DHSE +2 Result 2017
MP Board 12th Result 2017
Maharashtra Board HSC Result 2017
UP 12th Class Result 2017
Odisha CHSE Result 2017

boss patel said...

UP Board highschool result 2017
ISC Exam Result 2017
sslc result 2017
Bihar Board 12th Result 2017
mahresults.nic.in hsc 2017

minneapolis wordpress help said...

In the event you attain this pure intuition in which bull's-gape monster, great, countenance piece can certainly directly-or-rupture the possibilities intended for prick penetration as well as essential edify, you’re lard.minneapolis wordpress help

sarah saad said...

اسعار يتم تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
شركات تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة 2017
اهم شركات تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة

sarah saad said...

اهم شركات نقل العفش بالقطيف
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
كيف يتم تنظيف الخزانات بالمدينة المنورة

sarah saad said...

اسعار شركات نقل العفش بالقطيف
نقل اثاث بالقطيف 2017
كيفية نقل العفش بالقطيف

Dev Sena said...

Agra University Bcom Part 2nd Result 2017
Agra University Bsc Part 3rd Result 2017
Agra University Bsc Part 2nd Result 2017
Agra University Bsc Part 1st Result 2017
Agra University BA 3rd Year result 2017

Dev Sena said...

Agra University BA Part 1st Result
allahabad university Bcom 1st Year Result 2017
allahabad university Bcom 2nd Year Result 2017
allahabad university Bcom 3rd Year Result 2017
allahabad university Bsc 1st Year Result 2017

Dev Sena said...

allahabad university Bsc 2nd Year Result 2017
allahabad university Ba 2nd Year Result 2017
allahabad university BA 1st Year Result 2017
MLSU BA 1st Year Result 2017
MLSU BA 3rd Year Result 2017

Dev Sena said...


MLSU BA 2nd Year Result 2017
MLSU Bsc 1st Year Result 2017
MLSU Bsc 3rd Year Result 2017
DU JAT Result 2017
MPSE B. Com 1st Year Result 2017

Dev Sena said...

RBSE 8th Result 2017
Uniraj Admit Card 2017
CBSE NET Result

Lithium polymer battery said...

You may contact my previous clients who will tell you about work quality and make you choose my services.

Assignment Help said...

Very Informative post with image you gave to us, really helpful I would like to share something really helpful for education.
do my assignment for me