Search This Blog

Loading...

Monday, February 11, 2013

New Essay on Targeting and Intent

I've posted a new draft essay on ssrn, entitled Targeting and the Concept of Intent.  Here is the abstract:

International law generally prohibits military forces from intentionally targeting civilians; this is the principle of distinction. In contrast, unintended collateral damage is permissible unless the anticipated civilian deaths outweigh the expected military advantage of the strike; this is the principle of proportionality. These cardinal targeting rules of international humanitarian law are generally assumed by military lawyers to be relatively well settled. However, recent international tribunals applying this law in a string of little-noticed decisions have completely upended this understanding. Armed with criminal law principles from their own domestic systems, often civil law jurisdictions, prosecutors, judges and even scholars have progressively redefined what it means to “intentionally” target a civilian population. In particular, these accounts rely on the civil law notion of dolus eventualis, a mental state akin to common law recklessness that differs in at least one crucial respect: it classifies risk-taking behavior as a species of intent.

This problem represents a clash of legal cultures. International lawyers trained in civil law jurisdictions are nonplussed by this development, while the Anglo-American literature on targeting has all-but-ignored this conflict. But when told of these decisions, U.S. military lawyers view this “reinterpretation” of intent as conflating the principles of distinction and proportionality. If a military commander anticipates that attacking a building may result in civilian casualties, why bother analyzing whether the collateral damage is proportional? Under the dolus eventualis view, the commander is already guilty of violating the principle of distinction. The following Article voices skepticism about this vanguard application of dolus eventualis to the law of targeting, in particular by noting that dolus eventualis was excluded by the framers of the Rome Statute and was nowhere considered by negotiators of Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Convention. Finally and most importantly, a dolus eventualis-inspired law of targeting undermines the Doctrine of Double Effect, the principle of moral theology on which the collateral damage rule rests. At stake is nothing less than the moral and legal distinction between terrorists who deliberately kill civilians and lawful combatants who foresee collateral damage.

The essay was prompted by a multi-platform blog debate from last year.  For those interested in reading the old posts that sparked this debate, they can be here (Bobby Chesney), here (Kevin Heller), here (Jens Ohlin), here (Dapo Akande), and here (Heller again).


Comments welcome.


36 comments:

layciegrace said...

Unintended collateral civilian damage is a sad, inevitable scenario. It stays in the mind of a person who still has a heart. - Layce of an Australian writing service.

Mike Erik said...

Online Assignment Making Site
Dissertation Proposal Writing by UK

Mike Erik said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Assignment Provider Australia said...

My Assignment Help Site
Computer Science Assignment Help

malina loren said...

Adelaide Assignment Help for Student
Do Assignment Help from Australia

Iren vonnie said...

Online Essay Writer & Editing
Australian Essay Writing Service

Hr Assignment said...

yeah it was such an awesome blog that i have updated.. :)
HR Dissertation help

case study said...

Our website is number 1 in Case Study help, Case Solution & Case Analysis Help. Feel free to contact us to get your case studies done.
Case Study Solution Help

Programmer said...

Remote Object Programming Assignment Help is provided at ProgrammingDoc.com which is Number 1 website for Programming Homework Help and Online Programming Assistance.
Remote Object Programming

Assignments Provider said...

That is fantastic blog, I will pas this to the other peoples.
Social Issues Assignment Help

Mike Jasson said...

This is really great work. Thank you for sharing such a useful information here in the blog.
Finance Dissertation Help
Finance Term Paper

Wilson Larrie said...

College Term Paper Help
Capstone Projects Help

adison alex said...

for professional service you can contact us any time.
Essay Writers Australia for Hire

adison alex said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
adison alex said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Michael Jones said...

What a great information you shared with us, I am inspired by the method for the stage. It kept joined me regularly. Keep doing awesome. Thanks for sharing this blog article.
Assignment Help

Alex Jones said...

I personally like your post; you have shared good insights and experiences. Keep it up.
Assignment Help

Assignment Help said...

Nice post informative article keep doing this amazing job. Thank you.

Assignment Help

Alex Jones said...

Very well written article. It will be helpful to everyone who employee it, including me. Keep up the good work - can't wait to read more posts.
https://www.allassignmenthelp.co.uk
Assignment Help

Alex Jones said...

Hw Help
Homework Help
Such intelligent work on the subject and ideal way of writing here. I am really impressed! This post is a helpful overview of the particular topic and very actionable

Jeniffer Gomes said...

Our website is No. 1 in C/C++ Assignment Help and C/C++ Project Help. You can also hire us for C++ Projects Assistance. CHelpOnline.com is the Number 1 C/C++ Help Site in C Assignment Help niche.
C Homework Help

angelacooper839 said...

This post is really unique and good for all. thanks for sharing. Top Research Paper Site

Gaurav mehta said...

Nice work by admin Chhattisgarh Board 12th Result
Chhattisgarh Board 10th Result
PSEB 12th Result
PSEB 10th Result
Assam Board HS Result
Assam Higher Secondary Result
Assam HSLC Result
JAC Intermediate Result
Jharkhand JAC 10th Result
Orissa CHSE Result
BSE Orissa 10th Result
Orissa Board HSC Result
Telangana Inter 2nd Year Result
Telangana Intermediate Result
Telangana SSC Result Thanks

Blog Admin said...

Telanagana Eamcet Results 2016
Ts ssc Results 2016
Ts Eamcet Results 2016
Ap Eamcet Results 2016
Download AP Eamcet Exam Key 2016
Download Ts Eamcet Exam Key 2016

Rebecca said...

packers and movers Delhi
packers and movers Mumbai
packers and movers bangalore
Packers and Movers Gurgaon

Blog Admin said...

Happy Eid Mubarak 2016 Images
Eid Mubarak Quotes 2016
Eid Mubarak Images 2016
Eid Mubarak Whatsapp Status
Eid Mubarak Facebook Status
Eid Mubarak Messages 2016
Eid Mubarak SMS 2016
Eid Mubarak Wishes 2016
Eid Mubarak Fb Cover Photos 2016
Eid Mubarak Whatsapp DP 2016
Eid Mubarak Wishing Sms Messages 2016
Eid Mubarak FB Messages 2016
Eid Mubarak Profile Pictures Photos 2016
Eid Mubarak Latest SMS 2016
Eid Mubarak Quotes 2016
Eid Mubarak Wallpapers 2016
Eid Mubarak Wishes 2016
UP Board 12th Supplementary Result 2016
UP Board 10th Supplementary Result 2016
Bihar Board 12th Supplementary Result 2016
Bihar Board 10th Supplementary Result 2016
Happy Fathers Day Images 2016
Happy Fathers Day 2016 In USA
Happy Fathers Day 2016 Sayings
Happy Fathers Day 2016 Poems
Happy Fathers Day 2016 Songs
Happy Fathers Day Messages in hindi 2016
Happy Fathers Day sms in hindi 2016
Happy Fathers Day 2016
Happy Fathers Day Wallpapers 2016

Blog Admin said...

15th August Wishes In Hindi
Happy Independence Day Speech 2016
15th August Quotes 2016
15th August Messages 2016
Happy Independence Day Essay 2016
15th August Status 2016
15th August SMS 2016
Friendship Day Animated Pictures
Friendship Day Gift Cards 2016
Friendship Day Wishes 2016
Friendship Day SMS 2016
Friendship Day Messages 2016
Friendship Day Quotes 2016
Friendship Day Pics 2016
Friendship Day Pictures 2016
Friendship Day Photos 2016
Friendship Day Status 2016
Friendship Day Wallpapers
Friendship Day Images
All India Results
OU Results 2016
Osmania University Results
TS OU B.E 1st Year Result 2016
JNTU Results
JNTUH Results
JNTUH B.Tech R15 1st Year Result 2016
JNTUH 1st Year Result 2016 R15
RRB NTPC Results 2016
RRB NTPC State Wise Results 2016

Blog Admin said...

Eid Mubarak Images 2016
Eid Al Adha Status 2016
Eid Al Adha Mubarak Photos 2016
Eid Ul Adha Wallpapers 2016
Eid Al Adha Wishes 2016
Eid Ul Adha Messages 2016
Eid Al Adha Quotes 2016
Eid Mubarak Quotes 2016
Eid Al Adha Mubarak Images 2016
Eid Mubarak Wishes 2016
Eid Mubarak Photos 2016
Happy Independence Day Wishes In Gujarati
Happy Independence Day Wishes In Marathi
Happy Independence Day Wishes In Bengali
Happy Independence Day Wishes In Malayalam
15th August Pictures 2016
15th August Wallpapers 2016
15th August Photos 2016
15th August Images 2016
15th August Greetings 2016
15th August Wishes In Telugu

Rio August Olympics said...

The closing ceremony of the Rio de Janeiro Summer Olympics 2016 will officially take place on 21st of August 2016, Sunday evening at Maracana Stadium of Rio de Janeiro which begins at 20:00 BRT (UTC−3). This closing event will take place at the stadium after all the sporting events of the Summer Olympics 2016 complete.Rio Olympics 2016 Closing Ceremony.

Architecture Firm said...

One thing i love about your blog is the honesty you portray, i am sure that the people addressed to will exercise patience and understand. data entry services

Blog Admin said...

15th August Essay 2016
Happy Independence Day Status 2016
Happy Independence Day SMS 2016
Happy Independence Day Songs 2016
Independence Day Live Parade
Independence Day Live PM Modi Speech
Independence Day Watch Live President Speech
Friendship Day Animated Pictures
Friendship Day Gift Cards 2016
Friendship Day Wishes 2016
Friendship Day SMS 2016
Friendship Day Messages 2016
Friendship Day Quotes 2016
Friendship Day Pics 2016
Friendship Day Pictures 2016
Friendship Day Photos 2016
Friendship Day Status 2016
Friendship Day Wallpapers
Friendship Day Images
All India Results
OU Results 2016
Osmania University Results
TS OU B.E 1st Year Result 2016
JNTU Results
JNTUH Results
JNTUH B.Tech R15 1st Year Result 2016
JNTUH 1st Year Result 2016 R15
RRB NTPC Results 2016
RRB NTPC State Wise Results 2016

Blog Admin said...

Eid Images 2016
Eid Al Adha Images 2016
Eid Al Adha Quotes 2016
Eid Al Adha Messages 2016
Eid Al Adha Wishes 2016
Eid Ul Adha Wallpapers 2016
Bakra Eid Photos 2016
Eid Al Adha Status 2016
Eid Al Adha SMS 2016
Happy Independence Day India
15th August Wishes In Gujarati
15th August Wishes In Punjabi
15th August Wishes In Marathi
15th August Wishes In Bengali
15th August Wishes In Malayalam
Happy Independence Day India Pictures 2016
Happy Independence Day Wallpapers 2016
India 70th Independence Day Photos 2016
Happy Independence Images 2016
Happy Independence Day Greetings 2016
Independence Day Wishes In Telugu
Independence Day Wishes In Hindi
Independence Day Speech 2016
Independence Day Quotes 2016
Independence Day Messages 2016

Neil Wilston said...

Looking for getting good marks in c project help then get help from EssayCorp
c project help

Cctv camera dealers in Mumbai said...

Whether you are a retail store owner, a home owner or a business man, security is always an important matter of concern of all to protect people, property and resources from thieves, burglars and other unwanted elements. Nevertheless, there are numerous benefits and features of CCTV camera that makes it useful and invaluable device. It has fostered a sense of security in homes and work places. Here are some of the noteworthy benefits of CCTV installation:

Annapurna tiffin services said...

The main highlight of the menu is the vegetarian meals on offer - the vegetarian lite meals which come complete with dal, sabzi, rice, curd, rotis and all the extras like pickle and salad that go with it. A simple, wholesome meal is what you can expect at which will leave you happy and satisfied.

carpet cleaning services| said...

Different carpet cleaning services are provided to people and thus had made the lives of people quite easy. Carpets can not only be cleaned through the vacuum cleaners or some other devices but they can be cleaned by the person himself. Different types of carpet cleaners such as rental, compact and full sized cleaner are found by people in stores. People can use them easily and all the dust cab be wiped off easily and comfortably through it.
The person can manually clean the carpet through the use of the shampoo or some surf which needs to be wiped off from the carpet.