Search This Blog

Monday, February 11, 2013

New Essay on Targeting and Intent

I've posted a new draft essay on ssrn, entitled Targeting and the Concept of Intent.  Here is the abstract:

International law generally prohibits military forces from intentionally targeting civilians; this is the principle of distinction. In contrast, unintended collateral damage is permissible unless the anticipated civilian deaths outweigh the expected military advantage of the strike; this is the principle of proportionality. These cardinal targeting rules of international humanitarian law are generally assumed by military lawyers to be relatively well settled. However, recent international tribunals applying this law in a string of little-noticed decisions have completely upended this understanding. Armed with criminal law principles from their own domestic systems, often civil law jurisdictions, prosecutors, judges and even scholars have progressively redefined what it means to “intentionally” target a civilian population. In particular, these accounts rely on the civil law notion of dolus eventualis, a mental state akin to common law recklessness that differs in at least one crucial respect: it classifies risk-taking behavior as a species of intent.

This problem represents a clash of legal cultures. International lawyers trained in civil law jurisdictions are nonplussed by this development, while the Anglo-American literature on targeting has all-but-ignored this conflict. But when told of these decisions, U.S. military lawyers view this “reinterpretation” of intent as conflating the principles of distinction and proportionality. If a military commander anticipates that attacking a building may result in civilian casualties, why bother analyzing whether the collateral damage is proportional? Under the dolus eventualis view, the commander is already guilty of violating the principle of distinction. The following Article voices skepticism about this vanguard application of dolus eventualis to the law of targeting, in particular by noting that dolus eventualis was excluded by the framers of the Rome Statute and was nowhere considered by negotiators of Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Convention. Finally and most importantly, a dolus eventualis-inspired law of targeting undermines the Doctrine of Double Effect, the principle of moral theology on which the collateral damage rule rests. At stake is nothing less than the moral and legal distinction between terrorists who deliberately kill civilians and lawful combatants who foresee collateral damage.

The essay was prompted by a multi-platform blog debate from last year.  For those interested in reading the old posts that sparked this debate, they can be here (Bobby Chesney), here (Kevin Heller), here (Jens Ohlin), here (Dapo Akande), and here (Heller again).


Comments welcome.


159 comments:

layciegrace said...

Unintended collateral civilian damage is a sad, inevitable scenario. It stays in the mind of a person who still has a heart. - Layce of an Australian writing service.

Unknown said...

Online Assignment Making Site
Dissertation Proposal Writing by UK

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mike Edison said...

My Assignment Help Site
Computer Science Assignment Help

Unknown said...

Adelaide Assignment Help for Student
Do Assignment Help from Australia

Unknown said...

Online Essay Writer & Editing
Australian Essay Writing Service

Blogger said...

yeah it was such an awesome blog that i have updated.. :)
HR Dissertation help

case study said...

Our website is number 1 in Case Study help, Case Solution & Case Analysis Help. Feel free to contact us to get your case studies done.
Case Study Solution Help

Programmer said...

Remote Object Programming Assignment Help is provided at ProgrammingDoc.com which is Number 1 website for Programming Homework Help and Online Programming Assistance.
Remote Object Programming

Unknown said...

That is fantastic blog, I will pas this to the other peoples.
Social Issues Assignment Help

Mike Jasson said...

This is really great work. Thank you for sharing such a useful information here in the blog.
Finance Dissertation Help