Search This Blog

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Would A Federal District Court for Drones Increase Collateral Damage?

One of the more interesting recent proposals for curing the "due process" deficit in the Administration's targeted killings program is for Congress to create a federal court to approve drone strikes.  Senator Dianne Feinstein, among others, is championing this strategy.

I don't think it will work.  Here's why.

First, the court would be modeled after the super-secret FISA court for approving government requests for surveillance in terrorism cases.  Such courts impose a form of judicial review, yes, but there is little transparency and no adversarial process.

But there are bigger problems.

As some of my colleagues have already explained, it is unlikely and improbable that such a court could authorize specific operational strikes. That would be difficult to implement in real time, and might even be unconstitutional for infringing on the Executive Branch's commander-in-chief power. Rather, such a court would approve the administration's decision to place an individual's name on an approved target list.  A court would review the legitimacy of this decision with the power to remove the name if the individual does not meet the standard for being a functional member of al-Qaeda.

Although this is more plausible, I still don't think it will work.  In the end, I think it would just push the administration to avoid targeted killings and would have the opposite effect.  It would increase, not decrease, collateral damage.  Let me explain.

Suppose the government has previously used the kill list to govern the selection procedure for targeted killings.  The list serves as a clearinghouse for debates and ultimately conclusions about who is a high-value target.  If the administration decides that the individual should be pursued, he is placed on the list. If the administration decides that the individual is of marginal or no value, he is removed from the list or never placed on it to begin with.

Now imagine that a court is requiring that the list be approved by a judicial process.  Why would the administration have any incentive at all to keep adding names to the list?  Why not stop using it entirely?  It could then rely exclusively on signature strikes -- an important legal development well documented by Kevin Heller in his forthcoming JICJ article on the subject.  Such strikes would not be banned by the court because the US would not know exactly who it is bombing.

(I'm assuming for the sake of argument that the US is still engaged in an armed conflict with al-Qaeda and that the AUMF or some other statutory authorization for the President's pursuit of the conflict would still be in place.)

Essentially, this would be a case of willful blindness -- a concept well known to criminal law scholars.  The real benefit of targeted killings is that the administration knows the exact threat and only targets one individual.  That has changed warfare tremendously.  But the court system would push the military back towards the old system: target groups of individuals who are known terrorists or enemy combatants -- but you don't know exactly who they are.  You just know they are the enemy.  That's the system that reigned in all previous conflicts.  And there would be a disincentive to ever acquire more specific information.  Why have a drone hover over an area with known terrorists in order to determine, through surveillance, the exact identity of the individual's there?  That would only trigger the jurisdiction of the drone court.  So ignorance would maintain the legality of the strike.

I don't think that is what Congressional staffers have in mind.

45 comments:

bumbu pecel bali said...

http://bantalsilikon01.blogspot.com
aaabb

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb

Puspa Sari said...

Thanks for Nice and Informative Post. This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic
hidup sehat alami
tips hidup sehat
online business
kabar berita harian

Puspa Sari said...

Thank you very much! My friends and family members will be happy after hearing about this
jam tangan online murah
jam tangan online

Puspa Sari said...

Thanks a lot for sharing. Will check back later for more of your articles.
jam tangan online
grosir baju anak
tas wanita branded

Puspa Sari said...

Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial.
glenn colton
pretty social
jual jam tangan

Puspa Sari said...

thanks for his articel can menembah my insight on the internet,
cinta akik
gemstone
portal bisnis online
kolektor batu akik
koleksi batu akik
pusat batu akik

deky ardita said...


dear good article and I really liked your post, thanks because has shared with us
| http://seribu-manfaat.blogspot.com
| Financialnewss.com
| jualsepatuonlinemurah.com
| http://taswanitabrandedterbaru.com
| http://raja-akik.blogspot.com
| http://harga-batuakikterbaru.blogspot.com
| http://penggemarbatucincin.blogspot.com
l http://hargaokey.blogspot.com

Ananda Lolita said...


Thanks for sharing nice information with us. i like your post.
OkeJam.Net:Toko Jam Tangan Online
jam tangan murah
tas wanita branded

Rifle Scott said...

besttermpaper thats good site to visit

silvi landa said...

Agen Judi
Bandar Judi Online
Agen Judi Bola
Bandar Bola Terpercaya
Agen Casino
Bandar Poker Online
Agen Judi Terpercaya
Prediksi Bola
Agen Bola
Bola Judi
Agen SBOBET
Agen IBCBET
Agen Casino
Casino Online
Poker Online

aliya seen said...

WE know the statement of purpose law school which is quite important for all of us if we are studying for law school.

Akash said...

Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Pune
Packers and Movers in Bangalore

Akash said...

Packers and Movers in Gurgaon
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Packers and Movers in Mumbai

Akash said...


This article is really fantastic and thanks for sharing the valuable post.
Packers and Movers Gurgaon
Packers and Movers Mumbai
Packers and Movers Delhi

Allen jeley said...

This article tell us how to write a statement and how save in file for complete your assignment thanks for share it professional personal letter .

preeti malviya said...

Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers Pune
Packers and Movers Mumbai
Packers and Movers Gurgaon

preeti malviya said...


Packers and Movers Pune
Packers and Movers Bangalore
Packers and Movers Gurgaon
Packers and Movers Hyderabad
Packers and Movers Mumbai

Suraj Baba said...


Online Cake Delivery
Cake Delivery in Delhi
Cake Delivery in Noida
Cake Delivery in Gurgaon
Cake Delivery in Ghaziabad
Cake Delivery in Faridabad

Suraj Baba said...



Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Pune
Packers and Movers in Mumbai

Suraj Baba said...


Packers and Movers in Gurgaon
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Packers and Movers in Chennai
Packers and Movers in Noida

Anil Mishra said...

Good Post, I really appreciate your valuable information content. Keep always update this type of content.

Thanks

Packers and Movers Bangalore

Assignment Help said...

I like your article.Very useful article.Thanks for sharing keep it up…… Assignment Help

Mishra Suraj said...



Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Bangalore

Mishra Suraj said...


Packers and Movers in Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Pune

Ranjan Jha said...

Online Diwali Gifts,For More Info:
Diwali Gift Hampers
Diwali gifts for corporates
Send Diwali gifts online

Diwali Sweet Hampers
Diwali Chocolates Hampers
Diwali Dry Fruits Hampers

Packingmoving said...



Make home relocation hassle free with three simple strategies : -
Packers and Movers Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/
Packers and Movers in Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/
Packers and Movers in Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai.html

Packingmoving said...


Get a real picture of moving company exploring its customer reviews :-
Packers and Movers Gurgaon @ http://packersandmovergurgaon.in/
Packers and Movers in Gurgaon @ http://packersandmovergurgaon.in/
Packers and Movers Delhi @ http://packersandmovergurgaon.in/packers-and-movers-delhi.html

Packingmoving said...


Make home relocation hassle free with three simple strategies : -
Packers and Movers Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/
Packers and Movers in Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/
Packers and Movers in Pune @ http://packersandmoverpune.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai.html

Expert Movings said...

packers and movers gurgaon
packers and movers noida
packers and movers delhi
packers and movers delhi
packers and movers mumbai
packers and movers kolkata
packers and movers chennai
packers and movers delhi

Mohit Sharma said...

packers and movers in india@
https://quicksoluction.com
packers and movers in delhi@
http://quicksoluction.com/packers-and-movers-in-delhi.html
packers and movers in mumbai@
http://quicksoluction.com/packers-and-movers-in-mumbai.html
packers and movers in pune@
http://quicksoluction.com/packers-and-movers-in-pune.html
packers amd movers in gurgaon@
http://quicksoluction.com/packers-and-movers-in-gurgaon.html

HR Assignment Help Online said...

very well written post keep it up i really liked it, keep your valuable information content.

Reshma said...

Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Orissa 12th First Year Result So

Nice Article. Good to see this. Bihar Board 12th Results So

Nice Article. Good to see this. NBSE 12th 1st Year Result So

Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in MP Board 12th 1st year Result So

Thank you for the useful information. Check Mizoram Board 12th 1st year Result So

Thank you for the useful information. Check AP Inter 1st Year Results So

Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. MBOSE 12th 1st Year Result

Thank you for the useful information. Check COHSEM Inter 1st year Result So

Good information. Keep sharing this kind of useful info. CGBSE 10th Result

Thank you for the useful information. Check Goa 10th Class Result So

knight Presta said...

Unbelievably compelling details you’ll have mentioned, thanks a lot for posting.
Dentist in Dubai
Veneers in Dubai
Dental Clinic in Dubai
Dental center in Dubai

Assignment Help said...

Awesome article. Thanks for share.

Assignment Help

Rakhi.In.India.In said...

So offer Blossoms for gathering on the web with all the elite game plans :-
Flower Delivery in Delhi
Flower Delivery in Gurgaon
Flower Delivery in Noida
Flower Delivery in Ghaziabad
Flower Delivery in Faridabad

Rakhi.In.India.In said...

As every celebration in India is divided without a gift, the same goes for this peppy occasion rakhiinindia.in :-
Online Cake Delivery in Mumbai
Online Cake Delivery in Patna
Midnight Cake Delivery in Pune
Midnight Cake Delivery in Ranchi

Rakhi.In.India.In said...

As each festival in India is inadequate without a blessing, the same goes for this upbeat event rakhiinindia.in :-
Online Cake Delivery in Jaipur
Online Cake Delivery in Kolkata
Midnight Cake Delivery in Kota
Midnight Cake Delivery in Lucknow

Rakhi.In.India.In said...

Praise the event of adoration with your cherished one and blessing them these awesome blessing rakhiinindia.in :-
Online Cake Delivery in Bangalore
Online Cake Delivery in Bhubaneshwar
Midnight Cake Delivery in Chennai
Midnight Cake Delivery in Hyderabad

best seo company toronto said...

It as nearly impossible to find well-informed people for this topic, however, you sound like you know what you are talking about! Thanks

ALL CELEBRITY GOSSIPS said...

Happy mothers day 2017
Mothers Day 2017 is celebrated on

the second Sunday of May every year, so the 2017 edition of it will take place on

May 14.

Happy Mothers Day 2017 Quotes

Best Happy Mothers Day 2017 Quotes

in english for the celebration of this year Mothers day. Just select any of the

Quotes from our collection.A mother is a person who, seeing there are only four

pieces of pie for five people, promptly announces she never did care for pie. –

Tenneva Jordan

mother's day gifts 2017

Great mother's day gifts 2017 Ideas

For all that Mom does for her family, she deserves to be celebrated every day of

the year but especially on Mother’s Day.


Happy Mother’s Day 2017 Gift Ideas



Happy Mothers Day 2017 Quotes


Happy

Mother's Day 2017 cards


Happy Mothers Day 2017 Images Wallpapers

Pictures


Mother's day SMS 2017 From Daughter



Cheap Mother's Day Flowers 2017



Mothers Day 2017 Quotes


Mother's Day Brunch 2017 Recipes Ideas


Mother's day 2017 SMS,status text messages


http://www.mothersday2017.co/

http://www.mothersday2017.co/
http://www.memorialday2017.co/

mother's day
Happy mothers day 2017
Mother's day 2017
Mothers day gifts
Mothers day gifts 2017
Mothers day quotes 2017
Happy mothers day quotes 2017
Mothers day images
Happy mothers day images 2017
mothers day poems 2017
mothers day cards2017
happy mothers day images 2017
Memorial Day 2017

Neil Wilston said...

Nice Article. Well written and explained, the topic is very interesting. Thanks for sharing.
Computer Science Assignment Help

sarah saad said...

http://www.pearltrees.com/khairyayman/item193051311
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بجدة
شركة نقل عفش بالدمام
شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بجدة
شركة نقل اثاث بجدة

Jasmine Nolan said...

Business Finance Assignment Help & Business Finance Homework Help Business financing is all about how well you manage your assets and how you equip them.
Business Finance Assignments Help

Sam Rafferty said...


JAC Result
UP Board 12th Result 2017
mpbse
HBSE 12th Result 2017
GSEB HSC Result 2017

digi member said...

Jntuk 2-2 results